Music Born Of Fear Dmitri Shostakovich’s Symphony No. 5

Opinions

Following its premiere there was widespread speculation—from an ‘official’ review by Alexei Tolstoy to Shostakovich’s son Maxim’s remarks many years later—about just what Shostakovich was saying. Reading how others interpreted the music may help you decide what you think this controversial symphony means.

alexey tolstoy

“This movement is a light-hearted respite from what had come before.”
—Alexei Tolstoy

But Shostakovich’s son Maxim disagreed with Alexei Tolstoy and offered a much more sinister interpretation.

Maxim Shostakovich

“The critics call the second movement a Mahlerian waltz. I strongly disagree. Mahler was in his tradition, but this is not a waltz. It is the aggression of a soulless negative force. A machine of destruction."
—Maxim Shostakovich

Clearly the music affords widely varying interpretations. Compare the way that Maxim describes the tune of the Trio with the descriptions by Michael Tilson Thomas and the San Francisco Symphony's concertmaster, Alexander Barantschik:

MTT

“And then there’s a deluxe dance master with his little kit violin and his rubato raffiné.”
—Michael Tilson Thomas

Alexander Barantschik

“In the middle of that movement, suddenly a little ballerina starts a dance given to the violin solo.”
—Alexander Barantschik

Maxim Shostakovich

“Reh. 57, a violin solo, is a child’s voice from beneath a soldier’s boot. It is not a waltz. The flute repeats the solo, a defiant fist is raised.”
—Maxim Shostakovich


What's Your Reaction?

digit_seo
March 13, 2015

Best SEO Service Team Provide Buy Manual SEO service for gologle first page

digit_seo
March 13, 2015

Really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us.Great site and a great topic as well i really get amazed to read this
Read this topic:
Crypto

digit_seo
March 11, 2015

Kupongerna.se är samlingsplatsen för alla som älskar rabattkoder och erbjudanden. Dagligen uppdateras Kupongerna för att du alltid skall ha den senaste rabattkoden till hands inför ditt nästa köp.
rabattkoder

xsuftf
February 24, 2015

This content is written very well. Your use of formatting when making your points makes your observations very clear and easy to understand. Thank you!
hotel Vienna

savannah
February 6, 2015

I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing quality information. Thanks for sharing. buy assignment online uk

ayunksyah
January 19, 2015

The deceive is to explore a duty that choice answers my wishes further cohere to it. Along continued wear of a utility, the process presented grows better cultured to accommodate your flavor. pidato bahasa jawa

Post Your Reaction