City of Music: Folk & Folkways

Tavern
The many folk traditions Mahler encountered gave him a rich source of songs, dances, and legends.
“The Bohemian music of my childhood home has found its way into many of my compositions.”
Play
VIDEO:MTT on the Ländler
  • The Scherzo (the third movement) of Mahler’s Fifth Symphony is built on the rhythm of the Austrian folk waltz, or Ländler. He described the effect of the music: “Every note is charged with life, and the whole thing whirls around in a giddy dance.

  • Critic Maximilian Muntz scoffed at this movement: “Waltz and Ländler motifs, robbed of their naïve innocence and cheekily made-up in modern orchestral colors, whirl around in a contrapuntal cancan.

Mahler's Methods

Devoted to Counterpoint

Mahler’s command of counterpoint was rooted in his study of the past, but he used it in a uniquely expressive way. Essential to the effect was clarity of line: "In true polyphony the themes run side by side quite independently, each from its own source to its own particular goal and as strongly contrasted to one another as possible, so that they are heard quite separately."

  • In the second movement of Mahler's Fifth Symphony, five separate parts lend colors of pain (trumpets), defiance (horns), and struggle (strings), as the music tumbles towards a climax of despair.

Related Examples
Delighted by Polyphony
  • In this exuberant fugal passage from the Fifth Symphony's Finale, Mahler uses his skill in part-writing to recall the pure joy of the lively polyphonic music of the Baroque masters. The theme itself could be straight out of Bach or Vivaldi.

Related Examples

Farewell: Folk & Folkways

Tavern
The many folk traditions Mahler encountered gave him a rich source of songs, dances, and legends.
“The Bohemian music of my childhood home has found its way into many of my compositions.”
Play
VIDEO:MTT on Das Lied von der Erde
  • The first song in Mahler’s song symphony The Song of the Earth (Das Lied von der Erde), “The Drinking Song of the Earth’s Sorrow” (Das Trinklied vom Jammer der Erde), expresses a bitter acknowledgement of life’s realities: “Life is dark, as is death.”

  • The opening of the song sets the mood of bitter abandon.

Wanderer: Synagogue

Synagogue
Mahler’s Jewish heritage gave him both specific musical sources and an ear for the outsider’s voice.
“Always an intruder, never welcomed…”
  • At times I feel I am a solitary stranger everywhere! My whole life is one great homesickness.” The expressive “sighs” in the first movement of Mahler’s Second Symphony are a prime example of the way he achieved a musical portrayal of grieving and loneliness in piercing, searing lines.

Play
VIDEO:Baritone Thomas Hampson and the SFS perform Das irdische Leben

Another evocation of alienation occurs in the song “Earthly Life” (Das irdische Leben), about a mother trying to console her starving child:
"Mother, oh Mother! I'm hungry;
Give me bread, or I shall die!"
"Wait a little, my darling child;
Tomorrow we shall sow quickly."

City of Music: Synagogue

Synagogue
Mahler’s Jewish heritage gave him both specific musical sources and an ear for the outsider’s voice.
“Always an intruder, never welcomed....”
  • Mahler’s Jewish identity was a subject of much discussion among his contemporaries. The melodic shapes and intensity of expression were often cited as evidence.

  • Intensity could border on the histrionic, as in the first movement of the Fifth Symphony, when the tinny sound of a small band suddenly interrupts the solemn cortege.

Mahler's Methods

An Interval Distorted
  • In the second movement of the Fifth Symphony, the heart-felt leap of a ninth in the slow sad march becomes a circus-like“whoop-dee-do” in the quick one.

Related Examples

Farewell: Synagogue

Synagogue
Mahler's Jewish heritage gave him both specific musical sources and an ear for the outsider's voice.
"always an intruder, never welcomed...."
Play
VIDEO:MTT on Mahler's late style

Mahler's last works exhibit a simplification and a return to the styles and gestures of his youth.

  • Many pages of Mahler's late works, The Song of the Earth (Das Lied von der Erde) and the Ninth Symphony, are colored by the musical motive called the turn. As a boy, he would have first become aware of its expressive possibilities when he heard it in synagogue, in the chanting of the Torah and in the singing of many prayers. In the last movement of the Ninth Symphony, as the music grows in intensity, Mahler employs the turn more and more. Play the audio to hear the opening phrase. Then play the video to hear the passionate climax.

  • The second song in The Song of the Earth, "The Lonely Man in Autumn" (Der Einsame im Herbst), might be the most direct expression of Mahler's remark that "I think it is probably the most personal composition I have created thus far." Here too, the turn is an integral part of the violin line that accompanies the plangent oboe melody at the song's opening. "Blue mists of autumn float over the lake; the grasses are covered with hoar-frost. You might think an artist had sprinkled jade dust over the delicate buds."

Mahler's Methods

Play
VIDEO:SFS Principal Oboe Bill Bennett
A Farewell Turn

In Mahler’s later music, the turn, once a simple item of musical punctuation, comes to occupy a place of particular emotional significance. Here it is at the beginning of the last movement of The Song of the Earth (Der Abschied).

Related Examples

Wanderer: Church

Church
Music shaped by the sacred tradition reflects Mahler’s ongoing search for spiritual transcendence through art.
“O believe, my heart, O believe”
Play
VIDEO:SFS principal trombone Tim Higgins on a special moment in Mahler’s music
  • Although Mahler himself gave his Second Symphony no title, it is commonly known as the “Resurrection” because of its dramatic arc, which portrays a soul’s journey from death through the day of judgment and resurrection, along the way looking back at the world. As the composer put it: “The whole thing sounds as though it came to us from some other world. And — I think there is no one who can resist it. One is battered to the ground and then raised on angels’ wings to the highest heights.

Resurrection chorale
  • Mahler pondered the resolution of the Second Symphony for a long time before deciding on the choral finale, but his experience at the funeral of Hans von Bülow settled the matter: "Only the fear that it would be taken as a formal imitation of Beethoven made me hesitate again and again [to use a chorus]...the choir, up in the organ-loft, intoned Klopstock's Resurrection chorale. It flashed on me like lightning, and everything became plain and clear in my mind! It was the flash that all creative artists wait for — conceiving by the Holy Ghost!

  • The chorale is preceded by the Grosse Appel, the call to the Last Judgment.

Mahler's Methods

Primal Light
  • As the fourth movement of the Second Symphony, Mahler’s orchestration of the Magic Horn (Wunderhorn) song “Primal Light” (Urlicht) comes as a counterfoil to the comic tale of effort and frustration of the previous movement. Its spiritual certainty points the way to the transfiguration depicted in the finale’s last pages.

Related Examples
Soliloquies

Throughout Mahler’s world of invention, instrumental solos modeled after birdsong appear at critical moments.

  • In the Second Symphony, mixed in with the trumpet calls that represent the call to the Last Judgment, a flute solo suggests the smallness of a single bird in the immensity of space and time.

  • Many years later, in “The Farewell” (Der Abschied), from The Song of the Earth (Das Lied von der Erde), Mahler evokes the narrator’s intense loneliness with a desolate flute solo.

Related Examples

City of Music: Church

Church
Music shaped by the sacred tradition reflects Mahler’s ongoing search for spiritual transcendence through art.
“O believe, my heart, O believe”
Play
VIDEO:MTT on Mahler’s Vienna years
  • The end of the second movement of Mahler’s Fifth Symphony evokes the sounds of church chorales. The music reflects a particularly productive period in his life, when his job at the Vienna Court Opera allowed him the resources to build a home in Maiernigg, where he conceived the Fifth Symphony.

  • A dramatic chorale marks the climax one of Mahler’s settings of the poetry of Friedrich Rückert. In “Midnight,” (Um Mitternacht), the narrator suffers isolation and doubt until the final verse: “At midnight I put my strength in your hands: Lord of death and life, you keep the watch at midnight.”

Farewell: Church

Church
Music shaped by the sacred tradition reflects Mahler's ongoing search for spiritual transcendence through art.
"O believe, my heart, O believe"
Play
VIDEO:MTT on the turn in Mahler's Ninth Symphony
  • The first movement of Mahler's Ninth symphony establishes a mood of searching. Only later do we get a hint of what is to follow, as just before the climax of the movement Mahler employs a short turning motive that hearkens back to his earliest compositions. It is orchestrated for brass and strings to heighten the effect.

Mahler's Methods

Play
VIDEO:SFS Principal Oboe Bill Bennett
A Farewell Turn

In Mahler’s later music, the turn, once a simple item of musical punctuation, comes to occupy a place of particular emotional significance. Here it is at the beginning of the last movement of The Song of the Earth (Der Abschied).

Related Examples
Play
VIDEO:MTT on the "turn" in Mahler's music
Turning Points

Play the extended video on the right to explore Mahler’s highly idiosyncratic use of the turn in the Ninth Symphony.

Related Examples

Wanderer: Triumph & Tragedy

Parade Ground
Military signals, fanfares, and marches in Mahler’s music express a full gamut of emotion, from triumph to tragedy.
“The military band was the passion of my childhood.”
Play
VIDEO:SFS principal bass Scott Pingel on Mahler’s music
  • The first movement of Mahler’s Second Symphony was originally named Todtenfeier (Funeral Rites).

  • When Mahler played the movement for leading conductor Hans von Bülow, the older musician reacted strongly, as Mahler reported to his friend Friedrich Lohr: “When I played my Todtenfeier to him, he became quite hysterical with horror, declaring that compared with my piece Tristan was a Haydn symphony, and went on like a madman.

Mahler's Methods

Funeral Rites

Both Mahler’s First and Second Symphonies raise the question of whether Mahler intended his music to have particular extra-musical meanings. Throughout his life, Mahler struggled with whether and how to explain his music to the public. He originally named his First Symphony the Titan, and gave the movements the following titles:
—Spring without end
—A chapter of flowers
—With full sails
—Stranded! A funeral march in the manner of Callot
—From hell to heaven, as the sudden expression of a deeply wounded heart.
By the time of the music’s publication in 1898, he had withdrawn the second movement as well as these titles. Yet he returned to explanation in the Second Symphony, expounding his concept that the hero of the First Symphony is borne to his grave in the funeral music of the Second and that “the real, the climactic dénouement [of the First] comes only in the Second.”

Related Examples

City of Music: Triumph & Tragedy

Parade Ground
Military signals, fanfares, and marches in Mahler’s music express a full gamut of emotion, from triumph to tragedy.
“The military band was the passion of my childhood.”
Play
VIDEO:Listen to Mahler himself playing his Fifth Symphony on a piano roll
  • Mahler’s Fifth Symphony opens with a fanfare that instructs us to “pay attention” before it moves into a funeral march. We hear echoes of this fanfare at the end of movement.

  • In Mahler’s Seventh Symphony, the first movement march is now more of a universal expression, divorced from its military origins.

Mahler's Methods

Calls and Signals

Each of the regiments stationed in Iglau had its own band, and each band came from a different corner of Europe. Nevertheless, military signals were the same all over the Empire, and literal quotes of these trumpet calls abound in Mahler.

  • In the Third Symphony, the call of “Fall in!”

  • brings the daydreaming posthorn back to earth.

  • The Fifth Symphony opens famously and strikingly with a haunting trumpet solo that seems to warn us of approaching tragedy. The passage is made up of two common signals, changed from major to minor:

  • the General Appel (General Call)

  • and the call Habt Acht! (Take Care!)

Related Examples
Mocking or Knocking?

Mahler’s Fifth Symphony makes obsessive use of the “fate” motive of Beethoven’s Fifth.

  • Initially it’s a motif of gentle urgency (and also an inversion of the piece’s opening fanfare) that accompanies the most intimate music of the first movement.

  • In the second movement, the same music returns in a shriller orchestration, sounding like a mocking laugh or an accusing cry.

Related Examples
Syndicate content